The loudest loneliness in The Great Gatsby happens in the most crowded rooms. Loneliness and isolation in The Great Gatsby are not a quiet undertone the novel saves for a few melancholy passages; they are the condition the parties are built to hide, the truth the spectacle is staged to drown out. Fitzgerald fills his pages with orchestras, motorcars, hundreds of guests, and a man whose mansion blazes with light all summer, and then he arranges every scene so that the more people gather, the more alone his characters become. Read the novel for its loneliness and the glamour stops being glamour. It becomes a sound made to cover a silence.

Loneliness and isolation in The Great Gatsby explained, the solitude beneath the crowded parties - Insight Crunch

The claim this article defends is simple to state and easy to prove from the text: the novel surrounds its characters with people precisely to expose how separate they are from one another, so that the empty funeral at the end does not introduce a new sadness but finally makes visible what was true on every crowded page before it. Call it the paradox of crowds that conceal solitude. Gatsby throws the largest parties on Long Island and dies essentially friendless. Nick stands inside the city’s brightest rooms and feels himself watching from the street. Daisy sits at the center of a marriage and a social world and asks what she will do with the next thirty years as if facing a sentence. The book never lets a crowd mean company. That refusal is the theme.

How The Great Gatsby Defines Loneliness and Isolation

Loneliness in this novel is not the same as solitude, and the distinction matters for every reading that follows. Solitude is a person alone and at rest in it. Loneliness is the failure of connection in the presence of others, the felt gap between how surrounded a person is and how reached they are. Fitzgerald is almost never interested in characters who are physically by themselves. He is interested in characters who are mobbed and still unreached, who stand in a packed room and might as well be standing in the dark water Gatsby reaches toward in the first chapter. The novel’s loneliness is social, not circumstantial. It is what happens to people who have done everything the age told them would buy belonging and find themselves no closer to anyone.

What is the theme of loneliness in The Great Gatsby?

The theme of loneliness in The Great Gatsby is the argument that the novel’s world manufactures isolation beneath the appearance of connection. Beneath the parties, the marriages, and the social whirl, nearly every major character is cut off from genuine intimacy, and the crowded surface exists to hide that solitude rather than relieve it.

That definition sharpens once you separate the two words the title of the theme pairs. Isolation in the novel is the structural fact, the literal separateness of people sorted into East Egg and West Egg, into old money and new, into the living and the valley of ashes, each group sealed off from real contact with the others. Loneliness is the emotional experience of that fact, the inner registration of being walled off. The novel gives you both. It gives you the social geography that keeps people apart, the eggs facing each other across a courtesy bay, the green light on a dock close enough to see and impossible to reach. And it gives you the interior cost, the trembling man on the lawn, the woman counting down decades, the narrator who confesses he is simultaneously inside the party and outside it.

What makes the treatment unusual for a novel so associated with excess is that Fitzgerald never lets wealth or company stand as a cure. In most fiction loneliness is a problem money or society might solve, and the lonely character is lonely because they lack the means to belong. Here the lonely characters have every means. Gatsby has the house, the shirts, the orchestra, the guest lists that read like a census of the era’s glamour. He is the loneliest figure in the book. The novel’s argument is that the apparatus of belonging in this world is hollow, that the parties and the marriages and the casual crowds are forms without the substance of connection, and that a person can have all the form and none of the substance and so be more alone for the contrast. This is why the loneliness theme cannot be separated from the novel’s treatment of class and the American Dream. The same emptiness that hollows out the Dream hollows out the company. People who relate to one another through money, status, and use cannot relate to one another at all, and the result is a society of the unreached.

The reach of the theme is total. It is not confined to Gatsby, though he is its clearest case. Trace it and you find it in Nick’s outsider narration, in Daisy’s suffocated marriage, in Tom’s restless infidelity, in Myrtle’s doomed grasp at a life across the class line, in Wilson’s literal entombment in the valley of ashes, even in Jordan’s cool detachment that keeps everyone at arm’s length. The book is a catalogue of people failing to reach one another, and the catalogue is so complete that loneliness stops being a trait of individuals and becomes a property of the world they live in. That universality is the strongest evidence for reading isolation as the novel’s organizing condition rather than one of several themes. The disillusionment that overtakes the characters and the collapse of hope across the summer are inseparable from this failure of connection; the loneliness is what disillusionment feels like from the inside, the discovery that the crowd was never company. The novel’s most famous closing image, of boats beating against a current that carries them backward, is among other things an image of separation: each person borne alone in their own boat, straining toward a green light none of them will reach.

Where the Theme First Appears: Gatsby Alone in the Dark

The novel announces its loneliness before it shows you a single party. At the close of the first chapter, Nick steps outside and sees a figure on the neighboring lawn who turns out to be Gatsby. He decides to introduce himself, then stops, because Gatsby gives what Nick calls a sudden intimation that he was “content to be alone.” Gatsby stretches his arms toward the dark water, trembling, reaching for a green light Nick can barely make out across the bay. Then, when Nick looks again, Gatsby has vanished, and Nick is, in his own words, “alone again in the unquiet darkness.”

That tableau is the seed of the whole theme, and Fitzgerald plants it with deliberate care. Consider what he chooses for our first sight of the title character. Not the parties, not the rumors, not the pink suit. A solitary man on a lawn at night, reaching across water toward a light he cannot touch, while the one person who might have spoken to him decides he wants to be left alone. Gatsby’s defining gesture is an act of longing aimed at a distance, and the distance is the point. The green light is reachable to the eye and unreachable to the body, which is the exact shape of every relationship in the book. You can see the thing you want. You cannot close the space.

Why does the novel open Gatsby’s story with him alone?

Fitzgerald introduces Gatsby alone and reaching across water so that the reader meets his isolation before his glamour. The image establishes that Gatsby’s deepest condition is solitary longing, and every party that follows reads as an attempt to fill the emptiness this first scene reveals, an attempt the novel shows failing.

The phrasing rewards close attention. Nick reads Gatsby as “content to be alone,” but the scene contradicts the word content at once. A contented man does not tremble. A contented man does not stretch his arms toward the dark in a gesture Nick can only call curious. Fitzgerald lets Nick misread the moment, and the misreading is instructive, because it is exactly the misreading the rest of the world will make about Gatsby all summer. They will see a man at the center of a glittering social life and assume he has what he appears to have. The first chapter has already told us otherwise. The man at the center of the glamour is alone in the dark, reaching, and the people around him cannot tell the difference between a host and a hostage to his own longing.

Notice too what happens to Nick at the end of the passage. Gatsby vanishes, and Nick is left “alone again in the unquiet darkness.” The word again is doing real work. It tells us this is Nick’s recurring condition, that aloneness is where he keeps returning, and it quietly enrolls the narrator in the theme he is about to spend the novel observing in others. From the first chapter, the loneliness is not Gatsby’s alone. It belongs to the watcher as much as the watched. The green light, which the series treats at length as a symbol of Gatsby’s hope and its failure, is introduced here as a symbol of distance first. Before it means the American Dream or the orgastic future, it means the gap between a reaching man and the thing he reaches for, and that gap is the spatial form of loneliness. The novel’s organizing image is a man failing to touch what he can see, and Fitzgerald gives it to us in the last lines of chapter one so that everything bright that follows is read against a darkness already established.

How Loneliness Develops Across the Nine Chapters

The theme does not sit still. It deepens chapter by chapter, moving from a hint to a structure to an unanswerable fact, and tracing that movement is the difference between asserting that the novel is about loneliness and proving it. Fitzgerald builds the isolation in stages, and each stage strips away one more illusion that connection might still be possible.

How does the theme of isolation develop as the novel goes on?

Isolation develops from suggestion to certainty. The first chapters hint at solitude beneath the social surface, the middle chapters stage crowded scenes that expose the failure of connection, and the final chapters strip the surface away entirely, ending in an empty funeral that confirms the loneliness present all along.

The first two chapters establish the geography of separation. Chapter one gives us Gatsby alone on his lawn and the green light across the water, the literal gap between West Egg and East Egg made into an image. Chapter two carries Nick into the city for the afternoon with Tom and Myrtle, and there, at a small crowded party in a small apartment, Fitzgerald delivers one of the novel’s sharpest formulations of the lonely condition. Watching the scene from inside it, Nick says he was “within and without, simultaneously enchanted and repelled” by the variety of life. That doubled position, in the room and outside it at once, is loneliness rendered as a stance. Nick names the feeling that the whole book will dramatize: you can be present at the party and absent from it, can be a body in the crowd and a stranger to everyone in it.

The third chapter is the great party chapter, and it is here that the theme turns from suggestion to structure. Fitzgerald spends pages on the spectacle of Gatsby’s parties, the men and girls who come and go “like moths” among the lights, and then, at the height of the spectacle, he isolates the host. Nick’s eyes fall on Gatsby “standing alone on the marble steps,” watching his own party from a remove, not drinking, growing more correct as the crowd grows wilder. The image is precise and devastating: the man who built the party stands apart from it, separated from his own guests by the very sobriety and watchfulness that make him their host. Later that night, after the crowd has thinned, Nick records his own version of the same loneliness, noting flatly that “I was alone and it was almost two.” The party that looked like the densest gathering of human company in the novel ends with both the host and the narrator marked as solitary. The series reads the parties as a symbol of spectacle covering emptiness, and that emptiness is at bottom this one: the parties are crowds engineered to look like connection while producing none.

The middle chapters, four through six, sharpen the isolation into something colder, because they reveal that even the relationships the characters believe in are forms of separation. Gatsby’s pursuit of Daisy, which looks like the one connection that might redeem the loneliness, is shown to be a reach toward an image rather than a person, an extension of the green-light gesture from chapter one. The reunion in chapter five, for all its emotion, is a meeting between Gatsby and five years of accumulated longing, not between two people who know each other now. By chapter six the novel has made clear that Gatsby is in love with a version of Daisy that no longer exists, which means his great hope for connection is itself a form of isolation, a relationship with a memory. The reunion in chapter five dramatizes the loneliness even at the supposed moment of its cure. Gatsby fills Daisy’s house with flowers, stages the meeting with agonized care, and for an afternoon seems to close the distance he has reached across for years. Yet Fitzgerald threads the scene with signs that the connection is not what Gatsby believes it to be. He is reaching not for the woman across the tea table but for the five years of accumulated longing she has come to stand for, and the real Daisy, present and limited and frightened, cannot match the idealized figure he has built. When he shows her the shirts and she weeps over them, the emotion is real and also misdirected, a response to luxury and the dream of a recovered past rather than to the man himself. The chapter’s deepest irony is that the meeting Gatsby has organized his whole life around brings him no closer to another person, because the person he loves is a memory, and a man in love with a memory is the loneliest lover of all. The middle chapters thus convert even the novel’s central romance into evidence for the theme: the one relationship that might have redeemed Gatsby’s isolation turns out to be the purest expression of it.

The seventh chapter is where the loneliness becomes unbearable, and Fitzgerald stages it, characteristically, in the most crowded and overheated scene in the book. The confrontation in the Plaza, the drive, and Myrtle’s death pack the chapter with people and motion, and out of that density Fitzgerald lifts the novel’s most chilling line of isolation. In the airless luncheon before the city, Daisy cries out, “What’ll we do with ourselves this afternoon, and the day after that, and the next thirty years?” It is the cry of a woman at the center of a marriage and a social world who can see only an unbroken stretch of empty time ahead, no real company in any of it. The chapter ends with Gatsby keeping watch outside the Buchanan house, refusing to leave until he knows Daisy is safe, and Nick walks away and leaves him there in the moonlight “watching over nothing.” Gatsby’s vigil is loyalty aimed at a person who is, at that very moment, inside reconnecting with her husband. He guards a connection that has already dissolved. The phrase watching over nothing is the seventh chapter’s verdict on the whole theme: the characters keep faith with connections that are not there.

The final chapters complete the development by removing every remaining illusion. Chapter eight ends with Gatsby murdered in his pool, killed for a crime he did not commit, abandoned by the woman he reached toward across nine chapters. Chapter nine, which the series examines closely as the funeral scene, makes the isolation total and literal. Nick tries to gather mourners and discovers that the man who hosted hundreds has almost no one who will come. The development of the theme reaches its endpoint in a single flat sentence at the funeral, and the novel has spent eight chapters earning the weight of it. The loneliness that was hinted in the dark of chapter one and structured in the parties of chapter three is, by the end, simply the truth, with nothing left to cover it.

The Crowds That Conceal Solitude: A Loneliness Map of the Cast

The clearest way to see the theme whole is to lay each major character’s apparent social fullness beside the isolation underneath it. The pattern is consistent enough to name. Every character in the novel is granted a surface of belonging, a marriage, a party, a social set, a role, and in every case the surface is a covering over solitude. This is the framework this article advances, the loneliness map of the cast, and it is the engine of the argument that crowds in this novel exist to conceal solitude rather than relieve it.

Character Apparent social fullness The isolation beneath it
Gatsby Host of the largest parties in West Egg, hundreds of guests all summer, the center of every rumor Stands alone on his marble steps watching his own party, reaches across water toward a light he cannot touch, dies with almost no one willing to come to his funeral
Nick Inside every scene, the connector who knows everyone, dinners and parties and the confidence of every character Watches from “within and without,” sits “alone” at the end of the great party, narrates the whole story from a retrospective distance, finally retreats back West
Daisy A marriage, a child, wealth, a social world that revolves around her, the object of Gatsby’s devotion Asks what she will do with the next thirty years as if facing a prison term, reachable only as an image, sends neither message nor flower when Gatsby dies
Tom Marriage, mistress, athletic glory, a commanding place in old-money society Restless and aggrieved beneath the power, unable to hold anyone close, connected to others only through dominance and use
Myrtle A husband, a lover, a vivid social performance at the apartment party, a grasp at the glamorous life Trapped above a garage in the valley of ashes, used by Tom and discarded, killed running toward a car she thinks will carry her out
George Wilson A wife, a business, a place in the world of getting and spending Literally entombed in the ash-gray valley, the last to know of his wife’s affair, so isolated that grief drives him to murder and suicide
Jordan A celebrated public figure, a fixture of the social set, never without company Keeps everyone at the cool distance of a card she will not show, incapable of, and uninterested in, the honest contact the theme defines as its cure

Read down the right-hand column and the novel’s argument assembles itself. The isolation is not the exception in any of these lives; it is the rule the social surface is built to hide. And the table reveals something the individual scenes can obscure: the loneliness is not a private failing of one sad rich man but a shared condition, distributed across class lines, across marriages, across the living and the doomed. Gatsby’s solitude and Wilson’s are the same solitude wearing different clothes, the new-money striver and the ash-gray mechanic both sealed off from the contact they reach toward.

This is the article’s namable claim, the principle the table makes portable: crowds that conceal solitude. The novel surrounds its characters with parties and people precisely to expose how alone they are, which is why the loneliness reads loudest in the most crowded scenes and why the empty funeral does not introduce a new sadness but uncovers an old one. The parties of chapter three, the city apartment of chapter two, the overheated Plaza suite of chapter seven, these are the densest gatherings of people in the book, and each is the site of its most acute loneliness, because density is the contrast that makes the isolation visible. Take the crowd away and you would lose the measure of how alone the characters are. Fitzgerald keeps the crowd precisely so the solitude can be measured against it.

Which Characters Carry the Isolation

The loneliness map shows the pattern; the close readings show how Fitzgerald builds it character by character, with different textures of solitude for each. Understanding the theme means understanding that the novel does not write one loneliness and copy it across the cast. It writes a distinct isolation for each figure, and the variety is part of the argument that isolation is universal in this world rather than peculiar to any one temperament.

Is Gatsby lonely despite his parties?

Gatsby is the loneliest figure in the novel precisely because of his parties, not in spite of them. He throws them only to draw Daisy across the bay, fills his house with strangers, and stands apart from the spectacle as its solitary architect, reaching toward a connection the crowd can never supply.

Gatsby’s loneliness is the loneliness of the instrumentalist, the man who has converted every relationship into a means to one end. The parties are not pleasure; they are bait. He fills his lawn with hundreds of people for the single purpose of catching the attention of one woman across the water, which means the entire social apparatus of his life is a machine pointed at an absence. He does not know most of his guests, and they do not know him, and that mutual unknowing is the engine of the famous rumors, that he killed a man, that he was a German spy, that he is related to the Kaiser. A man whose own guests must invent a biography for him is a man no one has reached. When Nick finds Gatsby “standing alone on the marble steps” at the center of his own party, Fitzgerald is showing us that the host is the most isolated person present, because everyone else has come for the spectacle while he has come for one woman who is not there. The proof arrives at the end. When Gatsby no longer needs the parties, having reunited with Daisy, he fires his servants and shuts the house, and the crowd evaporates instantly, revealing that there was never any relationship in it to lose. The hangers-on who filled his lawn were not friends; they were consumers of his hospitality, and when the hospitality stopped they were gone. The novel makes this brutally clear in chapter nine, when Nick telephones the people who used to fill the house and finds that the man called Klipspringer, who had practically lived there, cares only about a “pair of shoes” he left behind, and is “sort of helpless without them” but apparently not helpless about Gatsby’s death. The party that looked like a thriving social world was a crowd of Klipspringers, present for the goods and absent for the man.

Daisy carries a different loneliness, the loneliness of the captive who has stopped expecting rescue. Her marriage to Tom is a structure of wealth and status that gives her everything except contact, and Fitzgerald lets her name the condition once, in the airless luncheon of chapter seven, when she cries out about “the next thirty years” as if the decades were a sentence to be served. The line is easy to read as boredom; it is closer to despair. A woman who can see only empty time ahead, with no real company in any of it, is describing isolation, and she is describing it from inside a marriage and a social world that should, by every appearance, have cured it. Daisy’s deepest isolation, though, is the one she shares with Gatsby without either of them grasping it: she is reachable to him only as an image, a voice “full of money,” an idealized memory, and never as the limited, frightened, finally careless person she actually is. The relationship the novel offers as its great love is, on inspection, two people reaching for images of each other across a distance neither can close, which is why it ends with Daisy retreating into her marriage and, in the novel’s coldest detail, sending no message and no flower when Gatsby dies.

Wilson carries the most literal isolation in the book, and Fitzgerald gives it a landscape. George Wilson lives and works in the valley of ashes, the gray desolation between the eggs and the city where the discarded of the gilded world pile up, and his physical entombment in that wasteland is the outward sign of a total disconnection from the life going on around him. He is the last to learn of his wife’s affair, sealed off even from the knowledge that everyone near him possesses. When grief finally reaches him it has no human channel to flow through, no friend, no community, no one to absorb it, and so it converts directly into violence and then self-destruction. Wilson’s loneliness is the novel’s argument carried to its extreme: a person so cut off that catastrophe is the only event that can break the isolation, and it breaks it only by ending him. Myrtle, his wife, dies reaching across the same class line Gatsby reaches across, running toward a car she believes will carry her into the bright life she has been denied, and the parallel is exact. Husband and wife are both destroyed by the gap between where they are and the connection they reach for.

Then there is Nick, the carrier of the theme who is also its narrator, and the relationship between Gatsby and Nick is the one bond in the novel that comes closest to real, which the series examines as the central friendship at the book’s heart. It is worth weighing what that friendship is and is not. Nick is the only person who reaches Gatsby with anything like understanding, the only one who, at the end, refuses to let Gatsby go down as the world’s invented monster. But even this, the warmest connection in the book, is shadowed by Nick’s confessed position of “within and without.” Nick is a watcher by temperament, a man who joins the party and narrates it at the same time, and his narration from a retrospective distance, telling the story two years later from back West, is itself a form of separation, the loneliness of the one who survives to record the others. That the closest thing to genuine connection in the novel runs between a dead man and his narrator, conducted largely after the death, is the final proof of how scarce real contact is in this world.

Jordan and Myrtle complete the cast of the isolated, each a variation on the theme. Jordan Baker carries the loneliness of the self-protected, the woman who has decided that the safest way through this world is to show no one her real hand. She is celebrated, never without company, a fixture of the social set, and she keeps everyone at the cool distance of a card she will not turn over. Nick is drawn to her and finally repelled by exactly this quality, the incurable dishonesty and detachment that let her move through the wreckage untouched. Jordan is not lonely in the way Gatsby is, reaching and unreached; she is lonely in the way of a person who has stopped reaching at all, who has chosen distance as a defense and so guaranteed the isolation she protects herself with. Myrtle Wilson is her opposite and her mirror. Myrtle reaches across the class line with the same doomed hunger Gatsby shows, grasping at the glamorous life Tom seems to offer, staging her vivid little performance at the city apartment as if borrowed wealth could make her belong. It cannot. She is used and discarded, and she dies running toward a car she believes will carry her into the bright world, killed by the very people whose carelessness she mistook for a way out. Husband in the ashes and wife reaching toward the lights, the Wilsons are both destroyed by the gap between where they are and the connection they reach for, the same gap that destroys Gatsby, proof that the loneliness crosses every line the novel draws.

The Symbols and Setting That Carry the Loneliness

Fitzgerald does not leave the loneliness theme to the characters alone. He builds it into the symbols and the geography so that the landscape itself argues for isolation, and a complete reading has to account for how the objects and places carry the theme as surely as the people do. The novel’s central images are, almost without exception, images of distance and disconnection.

The green light is the master symbol of the theme, and reading it for loneliness rather than for hope alone sharpens what it does. At the end of chapter one it is the thing Gatsby reaches toward across the dark water, visible and untouchable, and that combination is the exact geometry of loneliness: a connection close enough to see and impossible to close. The light sits on Daisy’s dock, which means the object of Gatsby’s longing is fixed in the world of East Egg he can never truly enter, and the bay between them is the small uncrossable distance that money and class make absolute. When Gatsby finally has Daisy beside him in chapter five, Nick notes that the green light has lost some of its enormous significance, because the symbol of distance cannot survive proximity, but the novel’s logic ensures the proximity is an illusion and the distance reasserts itself. By the closing meditation the green light has become the universal symbol of everything human beings reach for and cannot grasp, the future that recedes as we pursue it, and the loneliness of the reach is folded into that final image of boats borne back against the current, each separate, each straining.

The water and the bay deserve attention as more than backdrop. The novel separates its key figures by water again and again: Gatsby and Daisy across the bay, Long Island and the city across the river, the eggs facing each other across the courtesy water. Water in the novel is the medium of separation, the thing that lies between people who can see one another and cannot reach. Gatsby’s whole life is organized around a stretch of water he stares across, and his death comes in water, floating in his own pool, the element of his longing become the element of his end. The body drifting in the pool, undiscovered for a time, is the final image of a man alone, separated even in death from the world that used to fill his lawn.

The valley of ashes carries the theme at the other end of the social scale. Between the glittering eggs and the city lies a gray industrial waste where the discarded of the gilded world accumulate, and it is the novel’s landscape of total disconnection. Wilson is entombed there, sealed off from the bright lives that pass through, and the valley’s desolation is the visible form of the isolation the parties hide. Above it hang the eyes of Doctor T. J. Eckleburg, the faded billboard that watches over the wasteland, and those eyes are a brilliant emblem of the lonely condition: surveillance without care, a gaze that sees everything and connects with nothing, the look of a God who has gone or who never was. Wilson alone takes the eyes for the eyes of God, and his desperate need to believe someone is watching is itself a symptom of how utterly alone he is. The eyes stare at a place where no one truly sees anyone, and the contrast is the point.

What do the symbols of The Great Gatsby reveal about isolation?

The novel’s symbols are images of distance and disconnection. The green light marks a longing that can be seen but never reached, the bay separates people who can see one another but never connect, the valley of ashes shows total isolation, and the eyes of Eckleburg stare over a world where no one truly sees anyone.

Even the city carries the theme. New York in the novel is the place the characters go to escape the constraints of Long Island, but it offers no real connection, only the anonymous freedom of the crowd, the apartment where Tom and Myrtle stage a small party of near-strangers, the hotel suite where the central relationships shatter. The city is loneliness at scale, a place where a person can disappear into millions and be reached by none. When Nick imagines the clerks and young men dining alone in the metropolitan twilight, wasting the most poignant moments of night and life, he is seeing the loneliness theme generalized beyond his own circle to the whole modern city, a society of strangers in motion. The setting, in other words, does not merely host the loneliness; it is the loneliness, rendered as geography, and reading the novel’s places as expressions of isolation rather than scenery is one of the surest ways to deepen an analysis of the theme beyond what a plot summary can offer.

The Passages That Crystallize the Theme

Three passages carry the weight of the loneliness theme more than any others, and a strong essay on isolation in the novel works through these rather than gesturing at the parties in general. Each crystallizes a different facet of the argument, and together they form the spine of any close reading.

The first is the green-light gesture at the close of chapter one, already discussed, where Gatsby reaches across dark water toward a light he cannot touch. This is the theme in its purest, most spatial form, loneliness rendered as the unbridgeable distance between a reaching person and the object of the reach. Everything the novel goes on to say about isolation is implicit in this image. The light is visible, which is what makes the distance unbearable; a connection wholly out of sight could be mourned and released, but a connection close enough to see and impossible to reach holds the reacher in permanent longing. That is the precise texture of Gatsby’s whole life and, the novel suggests, of the lives around him.

The second is Nick’s confession in chapter two of being “within and without, simultaneously enchanted and repelled” by the variety of life. This passage crystallizes the theme as a stance rather than an event, the experience of being present and absent at once, in the crowd and outside it. It is the most concentrated statement of the lonely position in the book, and it is delivered, significantly, by the narrator about himself, which means the novel’s own perspective is structured by the very isolation it observes. Nick sees the loneliness in everyone else so clearly because he is living it himself, watching the party from the doubled vantage of the man who is both at it and beyond it.

How does the empty funeral show the theme of isolation?

The empty funeral crystallizes the entire theme in a single fact: the man who hosted hundreds dies with almost no one who will come. When Nick’s efforts to gather mourners fail and the narration records that “Nobody came,” the novel confirms that the summer’s crowds were never connection, and the isolation hidden beneath the parties stands fully revealed.

The third and decisive passage is the funeral itself in chapter nine, which the series treats as the novel’s closing reckoning, and the genius of it is its restraint. Fitzgerald does not editorialize. After Nick has spent days trying to assemble mourners, telephoning the people who filled the house all summer, reaching out to Daisy, to Wolfsheim, to the whole apparatus of Gatsby’s social life, the narration delivers the verdict in two words: “Nobody came.” The understatement is the point. The novel has spent eight chapters building the crowd, and it dismantles the crowd in a sentence, and the dismantling is so quiet that its full force registers only against everything that came before. Every guest, every orchestra, every rumor, every blazing window of the summer is answered by that flat “Nobody came,” and the answer exposes the whole social world as a thing without substance. The detail Fitzgerald lingers on is colder still: Nick records, “without resentment,” that Daisy “hadn’t sent a message or a flower.” The woman Gatsby organized his entire existence to reach does not mark his death with so much as a flower, which is the loneliness theme stated as plainly as a novel can state it. The reach of chapter one is answered, at the last, by total silence from its object.

Two small figures at the funeral complete the passage’s argument. Wolfsheim, Gatsby’s business associate, declines to come and offers a self-serving philosophy in his place, that we should “show our friendship for a man when he is alive and not after he is dead,” which sounds like wisdom and functions as an excuse, the rationalization of a man who gave Gatsby neither friendship in life nor respect in death. Against him stands the one unexpected mourner, the owl-eyed man Nick had met in Gatsby’s library months before, who appears at the grave though he barely knew Gatsby, and delivers the novel’s final epitaph, “The poor son-of-a-bitch.” That a near-stranger is moved to come while the woman Gatsby loved and the partner he enriched stay away is the cruelest arithmetic in the book. When the owl-eyed man learns that nobody else came, that the man whose parties drew people “by the hundreds” has been abandoned, his disbelief measures the gap the whole novel has been measuring: the distance between how surrounded Gatsby seemed and how alone he was. The crowds, in the end, could not produce a single flower.

The Counter-Reading: Are the Parties Real Connection?

The strongest objection to this reading is the obvious one. The parties are full of pleasure. People dance, laugh, drink, flirt, and form the swirling, glamorous society that has made the novel a byword for the Jazz Age. Is it not perverse to call the most sociable scenes in American fiction lonely? Does the reading not impose a melancholy the text does not support, ignoring the genuine gaiety Fitzgerald so plainly enjoys describing? A fair counter-reading holds that the parties are exactly what they appear to be, a vibrant social world, and that loneliness is the affliction of a few sad individuals within it rather than the condition of the whole.

The objection deserves a real answer, not a dismissal, and the answer is that Fitzgerald repeatedly stages the gaiety and then undercuts it within the same scene, so that the pleasure is never allowed to stand as connection. Look at how the great party of chapter three actually ends. The glamour Fitzgerald has lavished pages on dissolves, by the early hours, into something closer to desolation: a woman weeping as she sings, her tears running in black rivulets down her face, couples quarreling, wives being carried out, the whole crowd curdling into discord and collapse. The party does not end in communion. It ends in a scattering of unhappy, disconnected people, and Nick walks out of it noting that he was “alone.” Fitzgerald gives you the gaiety so that you will feel its evaporation, and the evaporation is the verdict. The pleasure is real, but it is the pleasure of strangers in proximity, not the pleasure of people who know one another, and it cannot survive the night.

Are the parties in The Great Gatsby a sign of connection or isolation?

The parties are a sign of isolation disguised as connection. Their pleasure is genuine but shallow, the camaraderie of strangers who do not know their host or one another, and Fitzgerald repeatedly lets the gaiety curdle into discord by the end of the night, exposing the crowd as a gathering of separate people rather than a community.

The decisive evidence against the counter-reading is the test the novel itself runs. If the parties were real connection, the people in them would have been Gatsby’s friends, and friends come to a funeral. The summer assembled hundreds of guests; the funeral assembles almost no one. The novel poses the question experimentally and answers it without ambiguity: the crowd that looked like a community proves, when tested by death, to have contained no community at all. You cannot maintain that the parties were genuine connection in the face of “Nobody came,” because the empty funeral is the controlled experiment that disproves it. The gaiety was sociability without bond, and sociability without bond is precisely the novel’s definition of the lonely condition: surrounded and unreached.

A further version of the objection asks whether any character escapes loneliness, whether the novel offers even one bond that survives its corrosive logic. The honest answer is nearly none, and the nearness of the exception is part of the argument.

Does any character escape loneliness in The Great Gatsby?

Almost no character escapes loneliness, and the single near-exception proves the rule. Nick’s loyalty to Gatsby, expressed mainly through his refusal to abandon him after death, is the one bond that approaches genuine connection, but it runs between a survivor and a corpse, which shows how scarce real contact is in the novel’s world.

The closest thing to an escape is the friendship between Nick and Gatsby, the one relationship in the book where someone reaches another person and is not merely using them. Nick is the only mourner who fights for Gatsby, the only one who refuses to let the world’s invented version of him stand, the only one who stays. But weigh what that friendship actually consists of. Its warmest expression is Nick’s loyalty after Gatsby is already dead, his insistence on a decent funeral, his telling of the story itself as an act of fidelity to a man who can no longer know it. The one genuine connection in the novel is largely a connection to a corpse, conducted by a survivor toward someone past reaching. That the book’s single counterexample to universal loneliness takes this form is the strongest possible confirmation of the theme. Even the exception is shadowed by separation, and the failure of connection that runs through the whole novel, which the series traces into the broader collapse of hope across the summer, is not relieved by Nick’s loyalty so much as memorialized by it. The reading that the parties are real connection cannot survive the funeral; the reading that someone escapes the loneliness cannot survive a clear look at what escape would have to mean. The stronger reading, the one the text enforces at every turn, is that isolation is the novel’s bedrock condition, glamour its disguise, and the empty grave its plain confession.

How to Turn Loneliness into an Essay Thesis

A weak essay on this theme says that loneliness is an important theme in The Great Gatsby and then lists lonely characters. A strong essay makes an argument about how the novel constructs its loneliness and what Fitzgerald is finally saying through it. The difference is the difference between cataloguing and reading, and the move from one to the other is what raises a grade and what makes a paragraph worth reading.

Build the thesis on the paradox rather than the observation. The observation, that characters are lonely, is true and unarguable and therefore not worth a thesis. The paradox, that the novel makes its characters loneliest in its most crowded scenes and uses the spectacle of company to expose the absence of it, is arguable, specific, and defensible from the text. A thesis worth defending might run: in The Great Gatsby, Fitzgerald constructs loneliness not as the absence of company but as its hollow presence, staging the novel’s most acute isolation in its most crowded scenes so that the empty funeral confirms rather than introduces the solitude beneath the glamour. That sentence gives a reader something to argue with and gives the essay a spine, because every body paragraph can then test the claim against a specific crowded scene.

Choose the evidence by scene, not by character, and let each paragraph pair a crowd with the solitude inside it. One paragraph takes the party of chapter three and reads Gatsby “standing alone on the marble steps” against the hundreds of guests around him. One takes the city apartment of chapter two and reads Nick’s “within and without” against the crowded little party. One takes the Plaza confrontation of chapter seven and reads Daisy’s “next thirty years” against the heat and density of the scene. And the final body paragraph takes the funeral and reads “Nobody came” against the summer’s crowds, closing the argument by showing the contrast resolved into open emptiness. Structuring the essay as a series of crowd-and-solitude pairings does the analytical work automatically, because the structure itself enacts the thesis.

Embed the quotations rather than dropping them. A dropped quotation sits alone in a paragraph with a citation and no analysis; an embedded quotation is woven into a sentence that does something with it. Do not write that Gatsby was alone and then quote “standing alone on the marble steps.” Write that Fitzgerald isolates his host at the height of the spectacle, fixing him “standing alone on the marble steps” while his guests dissolve into fraternal hilarity below, so that the architecture of the party throws the architect’s solitude into relief. The quotation should be load-bearing, doing argumentative work inside the sentence rather than illustrating a claim already made.

Anticipate the counter-reading inside the essay, because a thesis that pretends the parties are simply sad is weaker than one that grants their gaiety and then accounts for it. Concede that the pleasure is real, then show that Fitzgerald lets it curdle by the end of every night, and use the funeral as the experiment that settles the question. An examiner rewards the essay that has clearly seen the strongest objection to its own argument and answered it from the text. The strategy is the same one the strongest readings of any theme in the novel use: name the misreading, grant what is true in it, and defeat it with the passage that the misreading cannot explain. Here that passage is always the same two words at the funeral, and an essay that builds toward “Nobody came” as the proof of its thesis will land its argument where the novel itself lands.

The Verdict on Loneliness and Isolation in The Great Gatsby

The novel’s final word on loneliness is that it is not a mood but a structure, not the affliction of a few unlucky characters but the condition of an entire world organized around money, status, and use rather than contact. Fitzgerald’s achievement is to have hidden this condition under the most glamorous surface in American fiction and then to have removed the surface, slowly and deliberately, until the loneliness underneath stood fully exposed. The parties were never company. The marriages were never intimacy. The crowds were always a way of not being known. By the time the rain falls on the nearly empty grave in chapter nine, the novel has proved its case so thoroughly that the emptiness reads as inevitable, the only possible ending for a summer of people who could see one another across the bay and never reach across it.

What makes the reading durable is that it accounts for the novel’s beauty rather than denying it. The loneliness theme does not require pretending the parties are dull or the prose is grim; it requires seeing that Fitzgerald makes the surface beautiful precisely so that its hollowness will register, that the gorgeousness of the spectacle is the measure of the solitude it covers. The same instinct that makes the novel an elegy for the failure of hope makes it an anatomy of isolation, and the two are finally one subject, because the hope that fails is the hope of being reached and the disillusionment that follows is the discovery that the crowd was never there. To read the novel for its loneliness is to read it as a study of distance, the distance between West Egg and East Egg, between Gatsby and the green light, between a host on his marble steps and the hundreds below him, between a reaching man and a woman who will not send a flower.

For the reader who wants to test this reading against the text directly, the surest method is to return to the passages and weigh them in sequence, and the cleanest way to do that is to read and annotate The Great Gatsby free on VaultBook, where the full annotated novel, close-reading tools, a searchable quotation bank, and theme and motif trackers let you follow loneliness and isolation from the green-light gesture of chapter one to the empty funeral of chapter nine and gather the evidence in one place. The library keeps growing, and the loneliness theme is among the threads it is built to help a reader trace line by line, so the parties and the grave can be set side by side and the contrast that carries the whole argument can be seen at a glance. The verdict, once the evidence is gathered, does not waver: in this novel the crowd is the disguise and the solitude is the truth, and the loneliest place in The Great Gatsby is always the most crowded room.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Why is Gatsby so alone even though he is surrounded by people?

Gatsby is alone because the people around him are not connected to him; they are consumers of his hospitality. He throws his parties for one purpose, to draw Daisy across the bay, so the crowd is a tool aimed at an absence rather than a circle of friends. Most of his guests do not even know him, which is why they invent wild rumors about his past. Fitzgerald shows this directly by placing Gatsby “standing alone on the marble steps” at the height of his own party, watching from a remove, not drinking, separated from the revelry by his single fixed purpose. The proof comes at the end: when Gatsby no longer needs the parties, the crowd vanishes instantly, and at his funeral almost no one appears. The summer’s company was sociability without bond, and that is the loneliest condition the novel knows.

Q: How does loneliness connect to the American Dream in the novel?

The two themes are inseparable because the same hollowness that empties the Dream empties human connection. Gatsby’s pursuit of Daisy is his version of the American Dream, the belief that effort and wealth can win the life he wants, and it is also his deepest isolation, since he reaches for an idealized image rather than a real person. The novel argues that a world organized around money, status, and acquisition cannot produce genuine intimacy, because people in it relate through use rather than care. The valley of ashes, where the Dream’s failures pile up, is also the novel’s image of total disconnection. When the Dream proves hollow, the company proves hollow too, and the disillusionment that overtakes the characters is at bottom the discovery that the crowd they chased was never real connection.

Q: Is Nick Carraway a lonely character?

Nick is lonely in a particular way: he is the perpetual observer, present at every scene and fully part of none. He names his own condition in chapter two when he describes himself as “within and without, simultaneously enchanted and repelled” by the life around him, the stance of a man who joins the party and watches it at the same time. He ends the great party of chapter three noting that “I was alone,” and he tells the entire story from a retrospective distance, two years later from back West, which is itself a form of separation. His closeness to Gatsby is the warmest bond in the book, yet it is expressed mainly through loyalty after Gatsby’s death. Nick survives to record the others, and the loneliness of the survivor and the narrator runs quietly through his whole account.

Q: How does the valley of ashes show isolation?

The valley of ashes is the novel’s landscape of disconnection, a gray industrial wasteland between West Egg and the city where the discarded of the gilded world accumulate. George Wilson lives and works there, entombed in the dust, and his physical separation from the bright lives passing through is the outward sign of a total human isolation. He is the last to know of his wife’s affair, sealed off even from knowledge everyone near him shares. Above the valley hang the faded eyes of Doctor T. J. Eckleburg, watching over a place where no one watches over anyone, an image of surveillance without care. The valley shows that the novel’s loneliness is not confined to the rich at their parties; it reaches down into the ash-gray world the parties are built on, where isolation becomes literal entombment.

Q: Why does almost no one come to Gatsby’s funeral?

Almost no one comes because the summer’s crowds were never Gatsby’s friends. The hundreds who filled his house came for the spectacle, the liquor, and the free hospitality, and when the hospitality stopped they had no reason to return and no bond to honor. Nick telephones the familiar names and gets excuses or indifference; the man called Klipspringer cares only about a pair of tennis shoes he left behind. Wolfsheim declines and offers the self-serving line that one should show friendship to a man while he is alive, which conveniently excuses his own absence. Daisy, the woman Gatsby organized his life to reach, sends neither message nor flower. The novel records the result in two flat words, “Nobody came,” and the understatement is the verdict: the social world was a thing without substance, and death revealed that there was never any community in it at all.

Q: Is Daisy unhappy and isolated in her marriage to Tom?

Daisy is isolated inside her marriage despite its wealth, status, and apparent fullness. Fitzgerald lets her name the condition in chapter seven, when she cries out, asking what she will do with herself this afternoon “and the day after that, and the next thirty years.” The line reads less as boredom than as despair, the cry of a woman who can see only empty time ahead with no real company in any of it. Her marriage to Tom gives her everything except contact; he keeps a mistress, and the bond between them is one of shared carelessness rather than intimacy. Even Gatsby, who adores her, reaches her only as an image, a voice “full of money,” never as the limited person she is. Daisy’s isolation is the loneliness of the captive who has stopped expecting to be reached, which is why she finally retreats into the very marriage that confines her.

Q: How do East Egg and West Egg create separation between people?

The two eggs are the novel’s geography of isolation, a physical map of the divisions that keep people apart. East Egg holds the established old money, West Egg the newly rich like Gatsby, and the courtesy bay between them is a small distance that money and breeding make uncrossable. Gatsby can see Daisy’s green light across the water but can never truly join her world, and that visible, unreachable distance is the spatial form of the whole novel’s loneliness. The separation is social rather than geographic; the two communities face each other and do not mix as equals. The class line the eggs embody runs through every relationship, deciding who belongs and who only visits, and it ensures that even neighbors a short row across the water remain strangers in any way that matters. Geography in the novel is a diagram of human distance.

Q: What part does George Wilson’s isolation play in the story?

Wilson carries the novel’s most literal and extreme isolation, and it drives the tragedy. He lives entombed in the valley of ashes, cut off from the bright world that uses his garage as a waypoint, and he is so disconnected that he is the last to learn of his wife Myrtle’s affair. When grief finally reaches him it has no human channel to flow through, no friend, no community, no one to absorb it, so it converts directly into violence. His isolation makes him the instrument of the ending: misled about who killed Myrtle and who she was involved with, he shoots Gatsby and then himself. Wilson shows the loneliness theme carried to its breaking point, a person so sealed off that catastrophe becomes the only thing that can pierce the isolation, and it pierces it only by destroying him. His grief is loneliness with nowhere to go.

Q: Does wealth make the characters more cut off from one another?

Wealth in the novel deepens isolation rather than relieving it, which is one of Fitzgerald’s sharpest arguments. In most stories money is a route to belonging, and the lonely lack the means to connect; here the characters have every means and remain unreached. Gatsby owns the mansion, the parties, and the guest lists, and he is the loneliest figure in the book. The Buchanans have old money and a marriage and a social world, and they relate to each other through dominance and shared carelessness rather than intimacy. The apparatus of belonging that wealth provides, the parties, the clubs, the casual crowds, turns out to be form without substance, a way of being surrounded without being known. The novel suggests that money trains people to relate through use and display, and people who relate that way cannot truly reach one another, so the richer the surface, the emptier the contact beneath it.

Q: How does Fitzgerald use crowds to dramatize solitude?

Fitzgerald stages the novel’s most acute loneliness in its most crowded scenes, using density as the contrast that makes isolation visible. The great party of chapter three, the packed city apartment of chapter two, and the overheated Plaza suite of chapter seven are the densest gatherings in the book, and each is the site of its sharpest solitude: Gatsby alone on his steps, Nick “within and without,” Daisy facing her empty thirty years. The technique is deliberate. A solitary figure in an empty room is merely alone, but a solitary figure in a packed room is lonely, because the crowd measures the distance. By keeping the crowd present, Fitzgerald gives the reader a yardstick for the isolation, and when he finally removes the crowd at the funeral, the emptiness lands with full force precisely because the summer’s density made the absence measurable.

Q: What is the difference between solitude and loneliness in the novel?

The distinction is central to reading the theme correctly. Solitude is a person alone and at peace in it; loneliness is the failure of connection in the presence of others, the felt gap between how surrounded a person is and how reached they are. Fitzgerald is almost never interested in solitude. His characters are mobbed and still unreached, packed into parties and marriages and social sets and cut off all the same. Gatsby standing among hundreds of guests is not enjoying solitude; he is suffering loneliness, because the crowd around him supplies no contact. The novel’s loneliness is social rather than circumstantial, the affliction of people who have done everything the age promised would buy belonging and find themselves no closer to anyone. Reading the theme as solitude misses the point; the horror is not being alone but being among many and reaching none of them.

Q: How does the owl-eyed man at the funeral relate to isolation?

The owl-eyed man is the novel’s quiet measure of how alone Gatsby truly was. Nick had met him once, months earlier, marveling over the uncut books in Gatsby’s library, and he barely knew Gatsby at all. Yet he is among the only mourners who appears at the grave, and he delivers the novel’s final epitaph, “The poor son-of-a-bitch.” The cruelty of the arithmetic is the point: a near-stranger is moved to come while the woman Gatsby loved and the partner he enriched stay away. When the owl-eyed man learns that the people who once went to Gatsby’s house “by the hundreds” have abandoned him, his disbelief measures the gap the whole novel has measured, the distance between how surrounded Gatsby seemed and how alone he was. His presence honors Gatsby precisely because it is so unexpected, and it throws the general abandonment into sharp relief.

Q: Why does Klipspringer care about his shoes instead of Gatsby’s death?

Klipspringer’s phone call is one of the coldest details in the novel and a perfect compression of the loneliness theme. He had lived at Gatsby’s house so often that he was nicknamed the boarder, a man who took Gatsby’s hospitality for months, and when Nick reaches him after Gatsby’s death, he asks not about the funeral but about a “pair of shoes” he left behind, admitting he is “sort of helpless without them.” The triviality is the indictment. A man who consumed Gatsby’s generosity for an entire summer registers his benefactor’s death only as an inconvenience to his footwear. Klipspringer stands for the whole crowd of hangers-on who filled the parties, present for the goods and absent for the man. Through him Fitzgerald shows that the apparent friendships of Gatsby’s social world were transactions, and transactions end when the supply stops, leaving the giver alone.

Q: Is Tom Buchanan an isolated figure too?

Tom is isolated beneath his power, though his isolation looks different from Gatsby’s. He has a marriage, a mistress, athletic glory, and a commanding place in old-money society, yet he cannot hold anyone genuinely close. He relates to others through dominance and use, bullying Wilson, controlling Daisy, possessing Myrtle, and that mode of relation forecloses real contact. His restlessness, the sense Nick gives of a man forever seeking the excitement of some lost football game, signals an emptiness the power cannot fill. Tom is never physically alone, but he is never truly with anyone either, and the careless cruelty Nick finally diagnoses in him is a symptom of his disconnection: people who cannot reach others can smash them up without remorse. Tom shows that the novel’s isolation extends even to those who seem most secure, that wealth and dominance are their own kind of solitary confinement.

Q: How does loneliness drive the tragedy of the ending?

Loneliness is the engine of the catastrophe, not merely its backdrop. Gatsby’s isolation drives him to reach for Daisy across an unbridgeable distance, and that reach sets the tragedy in motion. Wilson’s total disconnection in the valley of ashes leaves his grief with no human outlet, so it hardens into the resolve to kill. Daisy’s isolation inside her marriage leads her to retreat into it at the decisive moment, abandoning Gatsby to take the blame for Myrtle’s death. Each character’s separateness pushes the plot toward its violent end: misled and alone, Wilson shoots Gatsby and himself; alone and unmourned, Gatsby dies in his pool; and the crowd that might have been a community produces no rescue and, at the funeral, no mourners. The tragedy is the harvest of a world in which no one can reach anyone, where isolation removes every check that human connection might have provided.

Q: Which quotes best capture isolation across the book?

A handful of passages carry the theme most clearly and anchor any strong essay. From chapter one, Gatsby is “content to be alone,” reaching across the dark water, and Nick is “alone again in the unquiet darkness.” From chapter two, Nick is “within and without, simultaneously enchanted and repelled” by life. From chapter three, Gatsby stands “alone on the marble steps” amid his own party. From chapter seven, Daisy asks what she will do with “the next thirty years,” and Gatsby keeps a vigil “watching over nothing.” From chapter nine, the funeral delivers the flat verdict, “Nobody came,” and Nick notes that Daisy “hadn’t sent a message or a flower.” Read in sequence, these lines trace the theme from its first hint to its final confirmation, each pairing a crowded or hopeful surface with the solitude beneath it. Together they form the spine of the novel’s argument about loneliness.

Q: How do I write an exam answer about loneliness as a theme?

Build the answer on the paradox rather than the observation. Do not simply state that characters are lonely and list them; argue that Fitzgerald constructs loneliness as the hollow presence of company rather than its absence, staging the sharpest isolation in the most crowded scenes so the empty funeral confirms what the glamour hid. Structure the response as a series of crowd-and-solitude pairings: the party of chapter three against Gatsby “standing alone on the marble steps,” the city apartment of chapter two against Nick’s “within and without,” the Plaza of chapter seven against Daisy’s “thirty years,” and the funeral’s “Nobody came” against the summer’s hundreds. Embed each quotation so it does argumentative work inside your sentence rather than sitting beside it. Concede that the parties are genuinely gay, then show Fitzgerald letting the gaiety curdle by the end of every night, and use the funeral as the experiment that settles the question. An examiner rewards the essay that names the strongest objection and answers it from the text.

Q: Why does Daisy send no flower when Gatsby dies?

Daisy’s silence at Gatsby’s death is the novel’s coldest confirmation of the loneliness theme. Gatsby organized his entire existence around reaching her, building the mansion, throwing the parties, and waiting years to win her back, and when he dies for a crime committed in her defense, she does not mark the death with so much as a flower. Nick records the fact “without resentment,” which makes it colder still, a simple statement of how completely the reach of the whole novel goes unanswered. Daisy’s silence is not only cruelty; it is the act of a woman retreating into the safety of her marriage and her wealth, choosing the careless self-protection that Nick will finally diagnose in her and Tom. The green light Gatsby reached toward across nine chapters answers, at the last, with nothing, and that nothing is the loneliness theme stated as plainly as a novel can state it.